Casper® Mattress Comparison

Casper® is an online bed-in-a-box marketer offering a "direct to consumer" business model touting savings to the consumer by cutting out the extra markup from a retail store. The Mattress & Sleep Company believes that once you have reviewed our comparable offerings that there are truly not any savings for the consumer.

The Mattress & Sleep Company has prepared this guide as a fair, factual comparison for the Casper® Mattress.

Disclaimer: We are not in any way associated with or affiliated with Casper®. Casper® is a trademark of Casper Sleep Inc.

After you've finished comparing, we're confident you'll love your MLILY mattress. Use Coupon Code "MLILY-50" (without the quotes) during the secure checkout process online, and we'll take $50 off any MLILY mattress order as a thank you for comparing.

Also, be sure to read The War To Sell You A Mattress Is An Internet Nightmare over at Fast Company.

  Casper® MLILY
Serene Ultra
Total Specialty Foam 1 ½" 3" 3" 2"
Comfort Layers
(top layer first)
1 ½" of 3.5 lb poly foam
1 ½" of 3.5 lb memory foam
1 ½" of 2.5 lb poly foam
3" of 3.4 lb Smart Foam (Feels like latex) 1 ½" of 3 lb gel memory foam
1 ½" of 3 lb memory foam
1" of 3 lb memory foam quilted to cover
1" of 3 lb gel ventilated memory foam
Base Layer 5" of 1.8 lb poly foam 5" of 1.56 lb poly foam 7" of 1.56 lb poly foam 1" of 2 lb poly foam
5 ½" 1,000 series pocket springs
(foam encased coils)
CertiPUR-US Certified No Yes - CertiPUR-US Certified
Oeko-Tex Standard 100 Certified No Yes - Oeko-Tex Standard 100 Certified
Warranty 10 Years1
Shipping Courier Delivery Only Free Courier Delivery or Free In-Home Setup in the Calgary & Edmonton areas.
Plus - Immediate In-Store Pickup of Popular Models & Sizes.
All models in this comparison are vacuum packed and rolled for easy moving by an individual person
Available Sizes All standard sizes All standard sizes
Queen RV (60 x 74 ½")
All standard sizes
Price - Twin XL $825 $499 $629 $729
Price - Double $1,075 $599 $799 $899
Price - Queen $1,175 $699 $899 $999
Price - King $1,275 $899 $1,099 $1,199
  Casper® MLILY
Serene Ultra

MLILY is a Tier-1 Manufacturer

Unlike most mattress brands, MLILY is the manufacturer of all components in their mattresses. They make their own covers and foam layers in their very own factory, which is in fact the largest memory foam mattress factory in the world. Virtually every other mattress maker simply purchases generic components from other suppliers, packages them together and slaps a brand label on. MLILY has direct control over their quality and consistency, and are not subject to last-minute specification changes from sub-suppliers.

Comfort Trial

Casper® offers a 100 night comfort trial, while The Mattress & Sleep Company does not offer a trial. When these trial periods are offered, the cost of this program must be built in to the mattress price. Our experience has shown that return rates on mattresses are quite low, even when selecting a model online that you haven't had the chance to try.

More about our Sleep Sound Guarantee®.

About Polyurethane & Memory Foam

If you're considering buying a memory foam mattress, our 'About Polyurethane & Memory Foam' guide is an absolute must-read.

About Warranty

1 - It is critically important to know that the length of warranty does not determine how long a mattress will perform 'like-new.' The average mattress lifespan today is approximately 3-5 years. This means some people keep their mattress for 10 years, while others may get 12 months before experiencing significant wear issues.

The Mattress & Sleep Company believes that warranty should not be a primary factor in determining quality.

About The Mattress & Sleep Company

We're a family business based in Alberta, Canada. The Buchfink family have been involved in the furniture and mattress industries since the 1970's. We believe in transparency, which is why we have created this comparison page. We realize that we cannot fill every mattress order in Canada. We trust that this section of our website will be helpful in setting you on the path to selecting the right mattress, at the right price. If you do like our philosophy, we would love to work with you.

Our Story | Why We're Unique


So there we have it. Four mattresses, four choices ranked in order:

  1. Purchase the MLILY Tranquil at a price which is considerably less than Casper® (savings of $325 to $475), yet is most comparable in feel.
  2. Purchase the MLILY Serene Ultra with a traditional memory foam comfort style, while saving approximately $175 to $275.
  3. Purchase the MLILY Harmony for a superior hybrid mattress experience while still saving $75 to $175.
  4. Purchase the Casper® mattress if you need a trial period and don't mind spending an additional $75 to $475.

One Last Thing

Use the following Coupon Code during secure checkout to receive a $50 instant discount on your order with The Mattress & Sleep Company. To receive the discount, simply purchase any MLILY mattress, in any size and we'll take $50 off your order.

Coupon Code: MLILY-50

MLILY Tranquil


$449.00 to $899.00 $399.00 to $749.00 CAD

MLILY Serene Ultra Mattress

MLILY Serene Ultra Mattress

$599.00 to $1099.00 CAD

MLILY Harmony Mattress

MLILY Harmony Mattress

$699.00 to $1199.00 CAD